Did he deserve 10 mins in bin, once? Twice? Sending off? Or penalties sufficient at the time? I thought the decision had a msssive out come of the result !!??

Accept defeat gracefully , your team just wasn’t good enough

Stuck watching in Rome due to work and both incidents were dubious at best. Commentators of course said there was nothing in them. But, this is the guy who always commits dubious looking incidents to the point where you may believe he’s clever enough to get away with them, if you want. Think of the times he’s stuck the boot into try scoring attempts etc.



Thank goodness neither incident took our lads out the game.



FWIW lots of neutrals on Twitter also believed he should’ve gone for the second one, clumsy error or not, since he’d already been warned.



Either way he didn’t have an outstanding game or come back to haunt us, wishing he had been binned, I guess? Plus I think taking Wigan down to 12 would’ve fired them up more than us.



Good riddance to him from Wigan anyway.

I’m not saying we should of won , but if most other players had done they they would of bin sin binned at the very least, massive call by the ref

Tomkins is a scummy cheat.



But I don't think either warranted a yellow,and it isn't the reason we lost.

He'll have more 10 minute breaks than a 1970s British Leyland worker next year at Catalans if he thinks he can carry on performing his little, errm, games.

You don't get Robert Hicks making big, bold decisions in big games. A yellow for both was probably the right decisions.



As for it having a big impact on the game, I'm not sure. I don't see you scoring even if they're down to 12. You didn't do enough with the ball. Ratchford's aimless and unsupported darts were your only threats.



Charnley certainly got one back for you with his one on Escare.

Champion player. All I can say. Wish we had someone like him.

I don't think we did enough to win the game. In the last 20 and with our positional game. I think he should have had a 10 minute break for the second offence I'm not sure we would have capitalised though.



Good game, the best team won, please sign josh drinkwater, he'd be perfect with Blake Austin.

Not good enough I'm afraid..and it'll be the same next season with brown in the halves...

Seemed to have his back to the attacker, stuck out a leg, then was fortunate to get a hand on, which gave the ref a huge cop out of not having to make a real decision.



Surprised that neither incident went on report.



BUT



Overall our halves weren't creative enough, and Wigan deserved the win.

Yes he’s a poop house and he’s not quite the player he was in his pre injury days but like Sean Long he has maintained his career as a great competitor so fair play to him I hope he enjoys his successful exit from the pies and can help bring something to Catalans.