did he ref the game well..for me he got the donald knock on wrong which they scored off..and were we that badly disciplined in the 2nd half??i think not

To me he was inconsistent. For example, one minute he penalised for not standing square then he would ignore it and I think we started to get frustrated by it.



However he didn't throw loose passes, pass into touch,knock on, miss tackles etc

I told you all he was crap but got slated for it. viewtopic.php?f=21&t=460844 Leeds must of been offside/markers not square on every PTB.

I told you all he was crap but got slated for it. viewtopic.php?f=21&t=460844 Leeds must of been offside/markers not square on every PTB.

Childs was not the reason for defeat. Deluding oneself if anyone thinks such.

If that's in reply to me, then i didn't say he was.



We lost due to woeful defending & goal kicking.

Quote Wire_74="Wire_74"I told you all he was crap but got slated for it. viewtopic.php?f=21&t=460844 Leeds must of been offside/markers not square on every PTB.'" you weren't offside once! and he missed briers taking out donald which led to a try. he made errors for both sides,how he missed the eastwood crossing was amazing, but he was better tonight than i have seen him this season

Quote Wire_74="Wire_74"I told you all he was crap but got slated for it. viewtopic.php?f=21&t=460844 Leeds must of been offside/markers not square on every PTB.'" you weren't offside once! and he missed briers taking out donald which led to a try. he made errors for both sides,how he missed the eastwood crossing was amazing, but he was better tonight than i have seen him this season

We had him last week at Hudds and did us for 11 pens on the bounce and we never got 1 in the 2nd half........some off his decisions are boggling to say the least.

I'm fed up of people moaning about the ref whenever we lose. At Headingley it was apparently Silverwoods fault. Yet funnily enough whenever we are winning there's not a problem. People shouting that the ref is 'bent' and 'trying to keep em in it' need to grow up

Personally I was disappointed with the ref today. He was by no means the reason we lost but he did give penalties I disagreed with and Leeds being the professional side they are, always scored off these decisions.



Leeds were consistently off side, I don't think anyone could not have seen this. But Childs let it go, so Leeds carried on doing this. Can't blame them. Just wish we were savvy like that!

A couple of obstructions were missed in key places BUT I thought the kits were way too similar today - I can't blame him for missing it!



The refs do their best in tough situations and fast games. But I do think the off sides and number of forward passes were awful.

Couple of mistakes but to be fair most of his calls were spot on.

Watched on tv, he made a few wrong/no calls, missed the obstruction (how i dont know player gave himself up), leeds threw a few too many forward passes that were not picked up (Buderus), didnt penalise leeds for lying on, (Monaghan penalised for dissent tackle after) but generally had a decent game

bet you didnt complain when briers pushed a leeds player and wire made a break from it!