I agree. Although their was little malice in it and he was immediately remorseful it was still a terrible tackle which resulted in Myler leaving the field, although I'm sure he'd have played on if the game wasn't over. He's only missed 2 mins of a game and should at least sit out 1 more.



The elbow to Sinfield's jaw was a cowardly cheap shot. I hope he does the same against NZ. We may just see his ar5e then.

that was the biggest disappointment for me - where were our forwards getting stuck in and putting Ferriol on his backside? the minimum we should expect this weekend is that any foul play is punished by at least one of our prop forwards.

Oh for a pack that contained the likes of Fairbank, Skerrett, Nickle, Farrell, Newton and Sculthorpe.



Bring back the biff.

Sending off was sufficient for my money, it was late in the game, the French forwards were exhausted and one of them threw a lazy swinging arm at a nippy halfback. One of the things the RFL look at when deciding these things is how balanced he was, if a player is balanced and gives a high shot he's more likely to have intended it that if he was off balance. I can't get the highlights video to play on sky sports right now but if memory serves he only had one foot on the floor which may well have gone some way to getting hm off the hook. The Sinfield incident on the other hand was malicious, he should have got at last a game for that, did he get let off or is that one pending? If that had happened in a more close, heated game it would have all kicked off.

i like that sending off was sufficient its international rl i wanna see some dirty hits and a bit of biff

I would agreree normally for sending off sufficient but it was 1 minute.

If he had gone in wih nasty intent then I think it would have to be at least 5 matches but it clearly was a genuine accident. Watching him over a few years I have never seen him as a dirty player before.

I agree. Nothing wrong with big hits but no place for the swinging arm. Making excuses for the time in the game, his body position or how sorry he looked doesn't wash with me. If we start allowing this kind of thing, they'll be lenient on the spear tackle next.

Disgraceful decision. How can being sent off for 1 minute be sufficient? Rogues also has it spot on. Had Sam been the victim we'd be knee deep in righteous indignation on here.

Totally agree!

Cliff Watson, Brian McTigue,Derek 'Rocky' Turner and Vince Karalius, any of them do for you Brian ?

All of them please Roy.