Gave ourselves far too much to do in the opening half hour. Pretty even game otherwise. Special mention for Johnstone. Tremendous attitude from the lad.

Well that was a shambles yet again. How long will smith keep his job, how many super league games has he won foe us? 2 in 20? Not counting the middle8's. Would another club put up with this? No doubt he come on wakey tv with the usual bull,, he should be a MP with the excuses he come out with. Get Jk in before it's too late again and we have to drag all fringe players in from the top teams to save us again.

Miller had a nightmare

We were poor but Bentham gave them 18 points due to errors.

I thought we suffered whilst Scruton was on the pitch. Our come back started when he limped off and then hit the buffers when he came back on gave away that head high that lead to Catalans moving from 26 to 32. Went straight off again then!



Loss by 13 against a star studded Catalans side lead by a rampant Dave Taylor doesn't seem too bad as an end result. But it's another "if only"

Very disappointed with the first 25 minutes and no team is going to win from that position.

Great comeback, while it lasted and Toupu was certainly the inspiration for that but, the effort, commitment and quality from the youngest

player on the field, Johnstone, brightened up a crap afternoon. The lad was utterly brilliant and unlucky not to add to his earlier well taken try.



BJB, whilst looking dangerous in attack, looks very shy in defence and why he wasn't busting a gut to get to the kick for their first try was just poor and it set the tone for the first 25 minutes of slow, lazy rugby league, which was the worst we've seen for a couple of years or more.



Someone needs to take charge on field as there doesn't appear to be any leadership out there.

I'd drop BJB and Miller for the next match. The only two areas that haven't been changed.

No coach could do much more with our squad. We have too many journeymen and players who are really not SL standard.

However put in a couple of class players in the squad and we would have enough to build a half decent team.

Why bring an international class player across to the other side of the world and then stick him on the bench? Absolutely baffles me! Completely different side while he was on the pitch. Brian Smith is not the messiah he's a very naughty boy

Our coach signed and retained some of the dross on field.we have no chance while we have finn n miller at 6 and 7

Very poor in the tackle for those first 20 - 25 mins you cant blame any Ref for that and Its been said that the first thing they do in training is contact work..well they need to up it then as even after that there was some poor tackles put in. Johnstone must have been told you have a free reign he was my mom stopped 2 certain scores and played well

We need o make A. Tupou Captain....imo he would make an excellent leader on the pitch. We desperately need a centre to partner Tom Johnstone, who was fantastic today, and a big strong forward to replace Scruton who is abysmal. Our go forward changed altogether the minute Scruton left the field and Tupou and Arona came on, the backs will never do anything until the forwards start dominating.