I think he adds a bit of un-predictabilty and 'magic' that our dull team of the last few years has lacked.



You can imaigne that on a big day like a Derby or Playoff tie he will either be superb or give away a massive error, which makes him exciting to watch

He joins wide running players like Brent Webb and Sam Tomkins who join the line on the arch and either score tries or set them up.



He offers so much more than Briscoe...or dare I say it, Steve Prescott!

Very happy with the signing. As others have said, it's great to see the support there when we get a half break. Against Warrington he could have had two try's if the play came off for him. He went through the gaps, it was only Ganson calling a forward pass or knock on that stopped him racing to the line.



And in a strange way, I'm kind of glad he made that error last week. At the time it w a game we had unr control, and one we went on to win. After seeing that he will get punished if he doesn't react quicker, I now expect him not to make the same mistake again and always get the ball dead. A least last week he did it in a game we won (although it did set up a very tense finish) rather than doing it two weeks down the line and costing us the match.



Again, happy with the signing and I hope (and expect) when summer arrives and the ground hardens we will see what he can really do.

Because of one daft error against Wakey people are somehow assuming he's a poor defender. Actually he's very good - he has a great pair of hands, catches everything coming his way, and has so far shown himself to be a great one on one defender (unlike the turnstile the dobbins have got).



The big question against him when he was signed was his injury record, there was far less to worry about him in terms of ability. Let's hope he keeps healthy because he's real quality.

Prescott,Briscoe and Tony have all done the same mistakes but 2 of those never got lambasted on here like some do.Mckinnon is 1st class...postional play superb,always supporting the runner,kick returns are good...what more do the bleedin moaners want.

In a lot of ways he is like Jordan Tansey, Tansey was very off the cuff, great one minute and then next with the brain farts and stupid mistakes. Such a shame he blew it, I do think fans like to have that slightly more interested look from a full back instead of the ambling about part of his game. Still so long as he keeps this up and cuts out the errors he could even get a sniff for MoS?

Some people are already yelling 'Run Straight!' or 'Run hard you lazy beep' at the KC, as though they expect McKinnon to suddenly transform into an 18 stone prop and barge through the line

I did say last year when he signed if he stays fit he will be an excellent signing, big improvement on Phelps and our best all-around FB since Prescott.



So far he is proving me right, haven't seen the Saints game yet, but watched ever other game,but haven't seen him drop a bomb or miss a tackle yet, looks good going forward and in 4 games has made 16 tackle busts.



Talking about Brain farts, I can remember only one this season last week against Wakey, made a couple of other errors but so does every other player.



Let's hope he stays fit.

I don't think he offers more than Prescott. For a start, Prescott had genuine pace. He could, and would, go the length of the field if given a sniff.

But on the other hand he seems to have more skill, there's pros and cons to both. All I know is this is the happiest I've been with a FB of ours since Prescott! But it's early doors yet.

Definitely. I think he maybe offers as much as Prescott in different ways, but saying he offers more doesn't seem right.

Agree!