Don't know much about him, other than watching him slide down the pecking order at Leeds and a short loan spell at our neighbours. A 1 1/2 year deal makes it sound imminent, but hooker is possibly the last place we need any reinforcements given we have 3 in our squad already. I'd sooner give Carlile a run there than bring in anyone else.

No thanks. Have 3 hookers already.

At the moment with the hookers we have he wouldn't improve the squad.I think Hodgson and Withers work well as a pair.

He was good in Lovejoy.

Would be surprised if this signing happened unless Sandercock sees Josh Hodgsons future in the back row and doesnt rate Carlisle. I quite like the look of Carlisle though in the small spells that ive seen.

I'd rather have kept Fish !

Didn`t think he was too bad whilst with us to be fair.

anybody would have looked half decent in that team

He impressed me when he did a stint for us.

Not for me, I imagine he'd be more likely to end up at Hull if Heremaia is knackered

With Withers and Hodgson do we need Mcshane?

well I dont think a 50yr old ish veteran will be any good for sl standard

Lol