Hull FC have signed him and as a Hull fan I'd like to have Trinity fans views on him. I understand he plays hooker or half back and while probably not starting he'll add depth to our squad next season.



My question is basically is he any good?



Cheers.

I think he WILL be good but there is some development yet.

A bit like when you got Miller. Good but expectations at Hull were too big too soon.

I think you will have to see quite a few injuries in front of him to get a game.

We already have one in Trueman!

There are always high expectations at Hull every season. I really don't see Smith making your squad any better

He will be better than Dwyer, so already improves the squad

And so the fire sale begins.

Lol. There's no sale.

People can just start walking away.

Crazy time of year - if you are half decent and you are with a club likely to go down, your agent will be texting you all day long with leads and potential offers - when your main job is still to keep focussed on the day job.



Imagine blokes like Whitbread - probably already got an agreement in principle or a pre contract somewhere like Warrington. Gets injured every other week so the fans think he is shirking. Who knows. Thankless task.

very talented player with plenty of improvement in him to come, if the coach is focused on improving him and giving him a chance hel do OK. Downside he may just be short of a yard for top level, time will tell

He's was a bit error prone when in the team. Fitted in well really. Best of luck to the lad.

He rarely had the chance in his favoured position so, we never got to see the best of him.

I think he's a much better player than we saw at Trinity but, he's not on his own in that respect.

Maybe, like young Crowther, his face didn't quite fit.